Accession Number : ADA326574

Title :   If Civilian Leaders Overrule Military Leaders and Direct Them to Eliminate a Division, What Type of Division Should be Cut: Army Heavy or Marine?

Descriptive Note : Research rept.,

Corporate Author : ARMY WAR COLL CARLISLE BARRACKS PA

Personal Author(s) : Mohr, Jerry T.

PDF Url : ADA326574

Report Date : 30 APR 1997

Pagination or Media Count : 51

Abstract : This paper addresses the developing political forces and budgetary issues that may lead civilian leaders to overrule the objections of senior military leaders and direct them to eliminate a division; either an Army heavy or a Marine division. Should this happen, the Department of Defense (DoD) should eliminate a Marine division, not an Army heavy division. (This paper does not address whether the DoD should cut an Army light division). This recommendation includes a detailed analysis of the following arguments. First, if all of the Marine Corps's infantry regiments were employed simultaneously, approximately three of the Marine Corps's eight regiments could neither embark aboard amphibious shipping nor marry up with maritime pre-positioned squadron (MPSRON) equipment in a benign environment. Second, the Army heavy division with its supporting elements including its corps slice and supporting air force possesses superior fire power both direct and indirect, compared to the Marine division and its supporting forces found in the Marine Expeditionary Force. Third, in a rapid power projection military, greater reliance on reserve forces cannot substitute adequately for active forces.

Descriptors :   *MARINE CORPS, *DECISION MAKING, *ARMY, *MILITARY DOWNSIZING, MILITARY RESERVES, COMBAT EFFECTIVENESS, MILITARY REQUIREMENTS, MILITARY STRATEGY, POLICIES, MANAGEMENT PLANNING AND CONTROL, COMBAT READINESS, MANPOWER UTILIZATION, AMPHIBIOUS OPERATIONS, MILITARY CAPABILITIES, ARMY OPERATIONS, MILITARY PLANNING, MILITARY BUDGETS.

Subject Categories : Personnel Management and Labor Relations
      Military Forces and Organizations

Distribution Statement : APPROVED FOR PUBLIC RELEASE